be nice to puppers
Fucking THANK you for this post!! Ive been waiting for the “dominant alpha” theory to die out. It gets me so heated i swear!!!
It’s so ridiculous that people insist on applying an incorrect theory about wolves to dogs, and then try to apply it to humans too
“The concept of the alpha wolf as a "top dog” ruling a group of
similar-aged compatriots,“ Mech writes in the 1999 paper, "is
particularly misleading.” Mech notes that earlier papers, such as M.W.
Fox’s “Socio-ecological implications of individual differences in wolf litters: a developmental and evolutionary perspective,”
published in Behaviour in 1971, examined the potential of individual
cubs to become alphas, implying that the wolves would someday live in
packs in which some would become alphas and others would be subordinate
pack members. However, Mech explains, his studies of wild wolves have
found that wolves live in families: two parents along with their younger
cubs. Wolves do not have an innate sense of rank; they are not born
leaders or born followers. The “alphas” are simply what we would call in
any other social group “parents.” The offspring follow the parents as
naturally as they would in any other species. No one has “won” a role as
leader of the pack; the parents may assert dominance over the offspring
by virtue of being the parents.While the captive wolf studies
saw unrelated adults living together in captivity, related, rather than
unrelated, wolves travel together in the wild. Younger wolves do not
overthrow the “alpha” to become the leader of the pack; as wolf pups
grow older, they are dispersed from their parents’ packs, pair off with
other dispersed wolves, have pups, and thus form packs of their owns.This
doesn’t mean that wolves don’t display social dominance, however. When a
recent piece purporting to dispel the “myth” of canine dominance
appeared on Psychology Today, ethologist Marc Bekoff quickly stepped in.
Wolves (and other animals, including humans), display social dominance,
he notes; it just isn’t always easy to boil dominant behavior down to
simple explanations. Dominant behavior and dominance relationships can
be highly situational, and can vary greatly from individual to
individual even within the same species.